If you live the EDC (Every Day Carry) lifestyle, you’re always looking for something better. When it comes to holsters, that “something better” usually boils down to three things: comfort, retention and versatility. At least, that’s what I’m always chasing.
Recently, I became aware of the Incog X holster. The Incog X is a collaboration between Safariland and Travis Haley of Haley Strategic, who originally designed the holster more than 10 years ago.
The Details
The Incog X is described as “a holster that adjusts for various carry positions while allowing for a full firing grip prior to draw. An improved clip strut design adapts to different carry positions using customized concealment shims that can be easily installed or removed without the need for any tools. An actuated finger tab flexes open to allow quick installation and removal from the belt. The optional mag caddy provides added functionality to keep everything close at hand.”
It is also stated that the Incog X uses passive-retention and adjustable-tension technology to provide a precise, customizable fit. Rigorously tested by Haley Strategic and the Safariland team, the Incog X is said to offer exceptional retention and a smooth draw, even during grappling and defensive tactics scenarios.
Material-wise, it’s described as “a microfiber suede wrapper” for next-to-skin comfort, paired with a Boltaron body for impact strength and resistance to chemicals and abrasion — making it suitable for harsh use and long-term wear.
All of that sounds great on paper. In the real world, though, what I need is simple: a comfortable holster that’s easy to adjust, locks the pistol in place, and offers strong support for today’s most common EDC pistols. The only way to find out if the marketing matches reality is to run it through a proper test.
Selecting the Test Pistols
The first step was choosing which pistols to run in the Incog X. That was an easy decision for me: my two favorite EDC pistols, the Springfield Armory Hellcat Pro and the Springfield Armory Echelon 4.0C.
Both are modern, capable carry guns with similar overall roles, which made them solid candidates for comparing feel, fit and performance across the same holster platform.
Ordering and Setup
From the Safariland website, selecting a holster is straightforward. After choosing the pistol make and model, you select your optic size and whether you need compatibility for a weapon-mounted light. From there, you choose color.
The holster features an attractive gray suede finish. I like it, but I will say this: I’d like to see more color and material options offered across the board, especially considering how popular the Incog X is.
Next, I selected my draw hand (right-handed) and moved on to the final option: the “Mag Caddy.”
The Mag Caddy is an attached magazine pouch that mounts to the holster body via screws. It’s made of the same material as the holster and blends in seamlessly.
I’ve seen this setup before, and while it’s a clever option, it has never really been my preference for EDC. I typically carry in the “true appendix” position — right over the anatomical appendix — and I’ve always found the attached mag caddy to be a little uncomfortable for daily wear.
Live The Armory Life. The latest content straight to your inbox plus an automatic entry to each of our monthly gun giveaways!
I’m also used to keeping my spare magazine either at the 9 o’clock position on the belt or in a clip-on pouch inside my back pocket. Don’t judge me — it’s what works for me.
Once the holsters arrived, I set both up identically so I could fairly evaluate their performance and comfort.
The first thing I noticed right away was the belt clip design. By having two smaller belt clips — one at each end of the holster — the Incog X was much easier to position exactly where I like it. It locked into place cleanly and stayed there.
The Modular Claw System
One feature I genuinely loved is what I’d call the Incog X’s modular claw system.
Yes, it has a claw — an attachment designed to push against the belt and rotate the grip of the pistol closer to the body. That helps reduce printing by pulling the grip inward.
The reason this stood out to me is simple: on many holsters, the claw is huge. Even if it does its job, it often creates a bulky, uncomfortable feel, especially during long wear sessions.
The Incog X approaches it differently. The small’ish claw includes three interchangeable inserts — small, medium and large. These inserts snap into place without tools, allowing you to fine-tune concealment without turning holster adjustment into a full workbench project.
The medium insert felt good at first, but I swapped it to the small insert and found that it fit my body and carry style perfectly.
After setting up the claw, I adjusted ride height and cant. I run my holsters straight (neutral cant), and I keep them as low as possible on the belt while still allowing a clean firing grip on the draw.
With both holsters configured the same way, it was time to put them through my testing process.
The Incog X Test
I ran a two-part test with each pistol. Both pistols are similar in size and offer identical capacity using their flat base magazine options, which helped keep things consistent.
The first part of the test was simple: carry each pistol for a two-week period. I carried everywhere it was legal to do so, using the holster in real life and through normal daily activities.
My goal was to evaluate two key points:
Comfort: Could I wear it all day without constantly shifting, adjusting or noticing pressure points?
Retention: Would the pistol stay locked in place and secure throughout the day without loosening, shifting or backing out during movement?
The results were very favorable with both pistols.
Comfort was excellent. I was able to wear the holster all day without it becoming a nuisance. Retention was exactly what I want in an EDC holster: secure, confidence-inspiring and consistent.
I never had a single instance of either pistol coming loose from the holster. The holster itself also stayed anchored to my belt all day long.
One of the most notable strengths of the Incog X was how easy it was to put on and take off. Even removing it while sitting down wasn’t a struggle, which is something I can’t say about every holster I’ve tested.
Range Work
Once I finished the daily carry portion, I took both pistols to the range for live-fire drills.
I ran multiple one-shot presentations and multi-shot presentations from concealment. The holster performed exactly as it should.
There were no hiccups. No sticky draws. No awkward hang-ups.
The pistols released cleanly when I needed them to, and they stayed put when they were supposed to. Honestly, that’s the entire point of a quality carry holster — predictable performance every single time.
Overall Impressions of the Incog X Holster
My overall impression of the Safariland Incog X is very positive.
Comfort: Absolutely. I could wear it all day and not feel like I’m fighting it.
Retention: Perfect. The pistol remained locked in place throughout the day without coming loose during normal movement.
Reliability: Excellent. On the range and in daily carry, it performed smoothly and consistently.
However, I do have one small note worth mentioning.
One of my favorite features of the Incog X is the suede-like exterior finish. It feels great against the body and adds real comfort for all-day wear.
But I live in the desert, where temperatures can hit 115 degrees for over 30 straight days during the summer. That means perspiration is part of life, and sweat management becomes a real factor in EDC comfort and maintenance.
I found myself needing to wash the holster every weekend just to keep it clean and fresh. This isn’t a dealbreaker, and it’s not something everyone will run into — especially if you live in a milder climate — but it’s worth noting if you’re carrying in extreme heat.
Conclusion
I get to test a lot of holsters. Some I like, some I don’t. But the Safariland Incog X has earned a permanent place in my EDC kit. This is one holster I can get behind — 100%.
It delivers the balance I’ve been looking for: strong retention, all-day comfort and dependable performance. The slim profile makes it easy to conceal, and the modular features allow you to dial in the fit without overcomplicating the setup.
If you’re looking for a modern appendix carry holster that stays comfortable and performs consistently, the Incog X is absolutely worth your attention. It’s now in my daily rotation, and I don’t see that changing anytime soon.
Editor’s Note: Be sure to check out The Armory Life Forum, where you can comment about our daily articles, as well as just talk guns and gear. Click the “Go To Forum Thread” link below to jump in!
Join the Discussion
Featured in this video
Read the full article here